News center

Xiaoniao's lawsuit against Yadea for unfair competition has finally won.


Justice may be delayed, but it will never be absent

On November 15th, the Tianjin Higher People's Court issued the Civil Judgment Document (2022) Tianjin Civil Final 670, Xiaoniao v. Yadea Unfair Competition. The court ruled that Yadea Company immediately cease the unfair competition conduct involved, that is, cease using the phrase "Yadea, a more high-end electric vehicle" in its product packaging, other packaging, stores, media, and various other advertising; and within ten days of the judgment's effectiveness, publish a statement on its official website to eliminate the negative impact caused by the unfair competition behavior on Tianjin Xiaoniao Vehicle Co., Ltd.

Since 2015, Yadea Company has engaged in false advertising and commercial defamation by contrasting Xiaoniao electric vehicles with the phrase "Because it's Xiaoniao, therefore it's high-end" using the phrase "a more high-end electric vehicle" on electric vehicle packaging, in stores, on high-speed rail, and in news media. This targeting is very obvious. The blatant printing of "a more high-end electric vehicle" on its product packaging is in stark contrast to Xiaoniao's packaging of "Because it's Xiaoniao, therefore it's high-end"; the font and format are basically the same. Because Yadea's actions have gained more trading opportunities while damaging the fair market order, causing corresponding economic losses to industry peers, Yadea's unfair competition has seriously infringed upon Xiaoniao's legitimate rights and

seriously disrupted the market competition order. Tianjin Xiaoniao Vehicle Co., Ltd. was established in May 2005. The phrase "Because it's Xiaoniao, therefore it's high-end" was exclusively created by the founder of the Xiaoniao Brand and has been used since October 2006 at an exhibition in Nanjing. For more than ten years, it has been promoted on CCTV and more than a dozen provincial TV stations and also promoted in numerous newspapers and magazines. Every vehicle's outer packaging box has the slogan "Because it's Xiaoniao, therefore it's high-end" printed on it. The slogan is printed in more than 30 provincial and municipal stores across the country, on outdoor advertising signs, parasols, inflatable arches, banners and brochures. After years of promotion, "Because it's Xiaoniao, therefore it's high-end" has become widely known and is practically a household name.

News